top of page

Conference presentations - must for a patent invalidation search. A case study


Patent Invalidation or Opposition Search is conducted to question the validity of a patent. Mostly it is conducted by defendants to invalidate plaintiff's patent in a patent infringement lawsuit; or when a patent application for a similar invention owned by someone has been filed by a third party. Invalidity search is focused around the claims and file history of the patent to be invalidated. In addition to revoking a patent/application, invalidity searches help perform IP due diligence.


Most straight forward method of invalidating a patent is to attack its novelty by presenting a prior art literature that has been present in the public domain before the first filing date of the patent application. This, however, is not always possible and often difficult to identify a carbon-copy (or novelty destroying) prior art. In such cases, the most frequently adopted method is to question the non-obviousness (or inventive step) of the target patent’s invention. In most jurisdictions, it is done by finding two prior-art literature and checking whether upon combination it covers the novelty aspect of the target patent’s invention.


This sounds like an easy task, but the main challenge lies with finding the appropriate prior arts that may attack the novelty or inventive step of the target patent. Most searchers start their search with patent documents in paid patent databases starting with broad searches and then narrowing it down (top to bottom approach) or starting with narrow patent searches and then broadening it up (bottom to top approach) depending upon the subject matter to be searched, followed by a non-patent search. Also, there are some searchers who start with a non-patent search (followed by patent search) to understand the technology domain, competition, main players in the technology domain, main inventors, similar products or finding prototypes in videos (on YouTube). Conducting both patent and non-patent literature searches is an essential feature of a comprehensive patent invalidation search.


However, despite following a well-structured plan for both patent and non-patent search, it is sometimes very difficult to identify any closely similar prior art. We, at Boolean IP, call such patents as perfectly drafted patents. For such cases, we gladly accept the challenge and find fun in invalidating such patents.


In a recent patent invalidity search, when our team was exhausted with everything they could do on paid databases for patent or non-patent literature, we chose to look at conference presentations. After a thorough searching and analysis, we found a document (in PDF form) that contained the pictures of hand written notes describing the subject matter of the target invention that was disclosed in a conference presentation. The date on which those notes were taken was well before the first filing date of the target patent. The document helped locate some further information about the contents of the conference. The document was a bang-on killer art and it helped in an easy out-of-court settlement for infringement lawsuit against our client. When we checked why that document wasn’t captured earlier in our search strategy (although it should have been), we found that since the subject matter was present in a pictured form of hand written notes in a PDF format, most databases couldn't have captured and deciphered it.


The out of the box thinking and structured approach of team working on this invalidity helped us learn that you cannot always depend on structured databases all the time, and reviewing conference presentations, specifically the handwritten notes, are a must for any patent invalidation search.


If you need a patent invalidity expert who not only understands the technology, industry, and your specific needs, but also stay with you on each step during assignment and make sure you get the results crucial for your win, then you are at the right place. Clubbing the experience and expertise of our techno-legal experts, and AI-powered tools, Boolean IP provides high quality IP solutions that help you succeed. Get in touch for your queries.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Couldn’t Load Comments
It looks like there was a technical problem. Try reconnecting or refreshing the page.
bottom of page